Google Ads


Site Stats

Home Means Nevada: Redistricting Congress "Fairly"

by: atdleft

Fri Apr 15, 2011 at 3:58 PM EDT


(Also at Nevada Progressive)

In our previous glimpses into redistricting Nevada's Congressional Districts, we discussed what would happen if The Legislature redraws the lines based on certain politicians' future aspirations. But this time, I'm throwing a curveball at you. What happens if The Legislature can't agree on a map?

Today, the fun really begins with a glimpse of a possible court drawn map.

atdleft :: Home Means Nevada: Redistricting Congress "Fairly"
Yes, you heard me right. Two law suits have already been filed, one by the Nevada Democratic Party and another by the Nevada GOP, and more legal action may follow if The Legislature drags on without a map ready for 2012. If the increasingly brutal state budget battle drags on to Summer Special Session with no agreement in sight, there's a good chance the gridlock will also extend to redistricting. And as much as Nevada Supreme Court justices do NOT want to wade into redistricting, I've been hearing that both they and the major parties are seeing it as more of a real possibility.

So what happens? Let's take a look at just that, as a few angry judges throw out the political memos and guide a nonpartisan team to draw "fair" lines.

Share photos on twitter with Twitpic

Share photos on twitter with Twitpic

NV-02 (The Dark Green District)

Population: 674,932
69.3% White (73.7% VAP)

The State of Play

As you can see above, this is still a Washoe County based district. The good news for Republicans is that Washoe's flirtations with Democrats can be offset by heavily Republican rural areas like Elko, Douglas, and Lyon Counties. However, the bad news is that swingy Mineral County and Carson City are also included. All in all, The 2nd District becomes slightly more Democratic.

Who's All In?

Now that Kirk Lippold and Sharron Angle are officially in, let the tea-nuttery begin! It will be to fun to see those two out-crazy each other, then watch as "poor" Mark Amodei and Brian Krolicki try to get some of those teabagger votes without going too far off the deep end.

On the Democratic side, State Treasurer Kate Marshall is sounding more and more like a real candidate.

The Wild Cards

However, Marshall may not be alone. 2006 and 2008 NV-02 Democratic nominee Jill Derby is also looking at the race, along with Assembly Member Debbie Smith (D-Sparks) and Reno City Council Member Jessica Sferrazza. Now that all out madness is ensuing on the GOP side, Washoe Dems are increasingly liking their chances here... But it still won't be an easy ride. Why? See below.

Estimated 2008 Results: 49-50% Obama (D)

Early Race Rating: Leans Republican for now, Tossup if Angle or Lippold wins the GOP primary

Share photos on twitter with Twitpic

NV-04 (The Purple District)

Population: 675,314
61.9% White (65.2% VAP)

The State of Play

Now here's where things start to get wild! Notice some changes? For one, it's the new district that now gets drawn into the rurals. The new 4th District starts in rural Churchill County (Fallon gets placed in NV-02 because it can be argued it shares a community of interest with the other Reno exurbs), but otherwise the other rural counties are left whole as the district stretches from Ely down to Pahrump, then finally to Clark County. And once the district crosses into Clark, it takes in northern rural areas, from Indian Springs to Overton & Mesquite, then drops into the valley to take in the once rapidly expanding Northwest and Southwest Las Vegas suburbs, as well as all of Summerlin and some whiter West Side neighborhoods.

In essence, this is THE classic swing district with a unique mix of rural Republican strongholds, urban Democratic bases, and a whole lot of evenly divided suburban battlegrounds that can very well go either way next year... And that's how the court will want it.

Who's All In?

Notice something else? There's no incumbent here! Even though there technically is one in Shelley Berkley, we all now know what she's up to. So in her absence, there should be a wild ride on both sides in vying for this seat.

On the Republican side, State Senator Barbara Cegavske's (R-Summerlin) wish will finally be fulfilled as she now has an open seat to compete in. But then again, she may get an unwanted surprise if local teabagger groups rally behind the newly crowned, tea-tinged superstar in State Senator Elizabeth Halseth (R-Northwest Vegas). State Assembly Member Scott Hammond (R-Northwest Vegas) may also feel the temptation.

On the Democratic side, Assembly Member Marcus Conklin (D-Northwest Vegas) may be real opportunity here. And considering his gracious concession earlier this month and offer to endorse Chris Giunchigliani for Las Vegas Mayor after 15 votes separated them in the primary, Larry Brown is busy re-earning goodwill that may come in handy should he run for Congress next year. (By the way, in case you were wondering, he's also apologized for the confusion over his support for SB 283 and domestic partnerships for LGBTQ families.) And unless the Nevada GOP can sideline Cegavske and Halseth in favor of a more mainstream nominee, Dems may very well like their chances here.

The Wild Cards

Hey, isn't it wild enough already!

Estimated 2008 Results: 51-54% Obama (D)

Early Race Rating: Tossup

Share photos on twitter with Twitpic

NV-01 (The Blue District)

Population: 674,765
47.0% Latino (41.2% VAP), 29.1% White (34.5% VAP), 14.6% African American (14.8% VAP)

The State of Play

Even if Shelley Berkley wasn't running for Senate, the court would not care where she lives or where she "wants" to represent. But now that she's definitely out of the picture, all bets are off! The 1st District contracts to just (all of) North Las Vegas and the older, more Latino and African American heavy parts of The City of Las Vegas, as well as a few heavily Latino unincorporated Clark County areas and the northern half of The Strip.

Who's All In?

State Senate Majority Leader Steven Horsford (D-North Las Vegas) hasn't done a great job of hiding his desire to head to DC. And thankfully for him, a court drawn map doesn't prevent that, as this is designed to be a VRA protected minority-majority coalition district.

However, the path isn't too clear for him. After all, this is a strong Latino plurality district, and State Senator Ruben Kihuen (D-North Las Vegas) is a fierce fighter who's gaining broader appeal as a strong, progressive voice in The Legislature. Since this district overlaps with nearly all of his current Senate district, Kihuen definitely can't be counted out.

The Wild Cards

State Senator John Lee (D-North Las Vegas) isn't stupid, so perhaps he can't entirely be counted out yet. But as I've said before, he's acting far too conservative this session to really gain traction in a Democratic primary here.

And sorry, Republicans, but there's really no GOPer who can compete here.

Estimated 2008 Results: 67-68% Obama (D)

Early Race Rating: Safe Democratic

Share photos on twitter with Twitpic

NV-03 (The Red District)

Population: 675,520
56.2% White (60.3% VAP), 23.1% Latino (19.8% VAP), 9.6% Asian American (10.0% VAP)

The State of Play

Now here's where things get really crazy! Remember, the court is overseeing the drawing of this map. The judges don't care what Joe Heck wants or who he wants to represent. All they care about are population equity and fair boundaries. So unfortunately for him, he's forced to accept a Henderson based district that keeps the entire city intact while stretching north into the strongly Democratic East Side (which can be argued shares a community of interest with most of Henderson), and west across The Strip to heavily Democratic Spring Valley (which can be argued shares a community of interest with The East Side, and is needed for population equity), and across Eastern Avenue to Democratic leaning Silverado Ranch.

However, Democrats shouldn't get too giddy here. Remember, ALL of Henderson is kept in here, including Joe Heck's own MacDonald Ranch/Roma Hills base as well as the opulent, affulent, & Republican dominant Anthem & Seven Hills communities. Also kept in are more GOP heavy Boulder City, along with the rural communities of Searchlight and Laughlin further south (as well as Primm, added in from NV-02).

Who's All In?

Obviously, Joe Heck wants another term. However, he will really have to rethink his strategy if The Legislature deadlocks on the state budget and redistricting gets determined in court. Since he's likely to be kept in what will at least be a Democratic tilting district, he will need far more crossover support than he got in 2010 to survive next year in a district President Obama will probably win by double digits again.

So obviously, Heck looks to be an inviting target for Assembly Speaker John Oceguera (D-Silverado Ranch). He's survived tough battles before, and he's in the fight of his life now over the state budget. He may feel ready to take on Heck...

But there's someone else waiting in the wings, someone who will have waited a year for the rematch she's been looking for. Dina Titus definitely shouldn't be counted out, especially since she only barely lost last time... And this time, many of the areas where she performed worst have been removed. Meanwhile, her East Side base is left intact, along with the Green Valley (Henderson) neighborhoods where she beat Heck.

The Wild Cards

Byron Georgiou has quickly turned from welcomed Democratic fundraiser to unwelcome Democratic pariah. Both Shelley Berkley and Harry Reid want him out of the Senate race, and rumors have surfaced about him possibly running for House instead. So will it be here? Or in the new NV-04 seat? Or maybe even NV-01? Whatever the case, a whole lot of Democratic strategists nervously await where Georgiou will land.

And of course, depending on what Joe Heck does, particularly how he votes in The House, there's a chance of him being called for "tea time" in the GOP primary.

Estimated 2008 Results: 55-57% Obama (D)

Early Race Rating: Tossup for now, Leans Democratic if Heck has primary woes & Dems get a top notch nominee

So there you have it. This is just one scenario of what might happen if redistricting Nevada's Congressional Districts is tossed to the courts for judges to decide and nonpartisan players to draw. An incumbent is thrown into jeopardy, two open seats lead to total feeding frenzies, and an epic rematch may be coming to doorsteps near me soon.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Outstanding...
This could actually wind up going from 1-2 to 4-0.

Great work as always. I'm hoping Georgiou gets out of the Senate race, and NV-04 sounds like a fine contest for him. Of course, I liked Dina Titus just fine, and I wouldn't mind her rejoining Congress - but she did underperform Sen. Reid rather significantly last year.

20, center-left independent, Auckland Central resident, MD-05 voter, OR-01 native


I'm willing to keep an open mind...
On Georgiou, but he does seem to rub off a lot of folks the wrong way. At the NSDP (NV Dem Party) Central Committee meeting in Reno last month, he was there... And just feet away, delegates were complaining about what he said about Shelley, certain candidates and organizations he wouldn't donate to, his aversion toward anything "progressive" or "liberal", etc. He may be able to buy himself plenty of TV and radio ads, but I'm starting to wonder if his campaign strategy mirrors Victor Chaltiel's too closely.

And while you can view Dina Titus as "underperforming" Harry Reid (and that is a valid argument), you also have to remember that Dina faced far greater challenges because she didn't/doesn't have access to most of the deep pockets in Reid's pocket. She had a tougher challenge against a less polarizing opponent, yet she lost by less than 2,000 votes while other vulnerable Dems in other parts of The West were losing by much bigger margins. If she can get 47% and within 2,000 votes in a terrible cycle in a district full of GOP strongholds who only know her from TV ads, she will likely have a much better shot in a district with a slightly improved PVI and centered around her East Side and Henderson neighborhoods she's been winning since 2006.

Yes, Virginia, there ARE progressives in Nevada!
24, gay male, Democrat, NV-03 (or 04?)


[ Parent ]
I don't see Georgiou surviving a primary there...
If he's posturing to the right. He's going to have to get his ass in line and kiss Sen. Reid's ring if he wants his name in the roll call of the 113th Congress, because I don't think Democrats are terribly short of candidates they can nominate instead, either in your NV-04 or in any other district in which Georgiou can run.

I'm wondering when the knives come out in that prospective Horsford vs. Kihuen primary matchup, too. Kihuen is an easy mark because he hasn't always played by the party's rules, but Horsford is in the unenviable position of running the ship, and he's got a target on his back because of that. The racial politics there are complex, too; Democrats hardly want to be seen as sticking a finger in the eye of either the Latino or the African American community in Clark County, certainly. But another thing to consider is seniority - as I understand in, Horsford is termed out, and Kihuen is still a relatively new member of the Nevada Senate. Kihuen might be able to secure some promises that he'll be considered next in line if Horsford leapfrogs from NV-01 to succeed Sen. Reid, or something like that, but that might be too far in the future to satisfy him.

You're the expert: who do you think comes out on top if there's a two-candidate primary between Horsford and Kihuen?

20, center-left independent, Auckland Central resident, MD-05 voter, OR-01 native


[ Parent ]
I've usually said Horsford...
Because he ultimately has final authority (along with Oceguera and GOP legislative leaders) over redistricting. But if The Legislature can't agree on a map and the case gets thrown into court, then I suspect all bets will be off and Ruben Kihuen will like his chances.

Again, the court will be under pressure to draw a strong Latino plurality minority-majority district. Even if The Leg does agree on a map, the case may still go to court if Latino advocacy groups think NV-01 is too diluted. But if there's no map from The Leg, then Ruben will probably be encouraged by a court drawn map that strengthens the voice of his own East North Las Vegas/Downtown Las Vegas/ East Las Vegas base. In addition, both candidates are helped by the removal of Summerlin (that Shelley had insisted on 10 years ago, so she could live in the district and have the district she wanted).

Yes, Virginia, there ARE progressives in Nevada!
24, gay male, Democrat, NV-03 (or 04?)


[ Parent ]
For all you Nevadans--
What's the liberal/conservative split on the state Supreme Court? Or are they generally even-keeled regardless of who appointed them? I know with redistricting, courts often freak out regardless of partisan leanings and try to be as fair-minded as possible, so is that something we could expect here? Just curious.

Male, 20; living in MN-6 (unfortunately), born NJ-7

4-3 Republican-Democrat (Registered)
I don't know the intricacies of the court's politics, but Justices Cherry, Saitta, and Hardesty are registered Democrats. Justices Douglas, Parraguire, Pickering and Gibbons are registered Republicans.

These divisions don't matter in some states (see, e.g., Iowa in 2010), but I'm not sure if the partisan division here is an ideological division similar to our current SCOTUS, or if it's more nuanced. Would love to hear from some folks with first-hand experience in NV courts about it, though.

Interestingly, NV is one of the largest states (if not the largest, now) without an intermediate Court of Appeals. According to my BF, who follows a bit of NV court politics, NV justices are the most overworked of any state SC justices in the US.  

24, SSP Gay Caucus Policy Committee Chair, Western Democrat; CO-05 (home), CA-14 (law school)


[ Parent ]
Not so much...
There really aren't any Scalia type radical right flame throwers on our court. Honestly, it's more about the gaming and mining conglomerates getting what they want.

And yes, our Supreme Court IS the most overworked in the country. There was an advisory initiative last fall on whether to create courts of appeals, but that was voted down (probably because folks were irked over the cost) and legislators will have to continue to mull over how to make it happen so that The Supreme Court's docket is no longer so impossibly full.

Yes, Virginia, there ARE progressives in Nevada!
24, gay male, Democrat, NV-03 (or 04?)


[ Parent ]
A lack of an intermediate court
Makes sense in a place like AK, VT, and WY, but not in a state as large as Nevada. Two Courts of Appeals, with compulsory review, and a Supreme Court with discretionary appellate review would make much more sense.  

24, SSP Gay Caucus Policy Committee Chair, Western Democrat; CO-05 (home), CA-14 (law school)

[ Parent ]
OT, but Heller is going to be hit hard for his vote on the Ryan Budget
if the NVSDP's website is any indication.
http://www.nvdems.com/press/en...

Also, this map is pretty good and resembles what a non-partisan court or an Iowa-style commission would do.

Ad hoc, ad loc and quid pro quo!
So little time, so much to know!



Copyright 2003-2010 Swing State Project LLC

Primary Sponsor

You're not running for second place. Is your website? See why Campaign Engine is ranked #1 in software and support among Progressive-only Internet firms. http://www.mediamezcla.com/

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About the Site

SSP Resources

Blogroll

Powered by: SoapBlox