Google Ads


Site Stats

IN-03: Mark Souder (R) Resigning Due to Affair with Staffer

by: DavidNYC

Tue May 18, 2010 at 9:46 AM EDT


This was... unexpected:

Rep. Mark Souder (R-Ind.), a former congressional staffer who was elected to the House in the Republican revolution of 1994, has told colleagues he will resign Tuesday because of an affair with a female aide, a House GOP official told POLITICO.

Souder has scheduled an announcement about his future for 10 a.m. today at his congressional office in Ft. Wayne.

Souder is married and has three children.

He informed Minority Leader John Boehner (R-Ohio) of his decision on Sunday, according to GOP sources.

Souder, as you'll recall, squeaked out of his primary earlier this month with just 48% of the vote. Last cycle, he handily dispatched Dem Mike Montagano in a race many (SSP included) expected to be a lot closer. We'll bring you details on any word of a special as soon as we have them.

UPDATE: The law:

    Sec. 1. A special election shall be held in the following cases:
       (3) Whenever a vacancy occurs in the office of United States Representative unless the vacancy occurs less than thirty (30) days before a general election.

Also, when Julia Carson's death created a vacancy in IN-07 back in 2008, news accounts at the time said that the special election had to have been held within 60 days of the vacancy. Presumably that is the timetable we'll be following here, but we will do some more research on this question. (James)

MORE UPDATE: Hoo boy, this is rich. Souder and his mistress actuallly made an anti-sex tape together: they appeared together in a video in favor of abstinence-only education.

A couple other interesting observations from the comments: prior to Andre Carson's election, the last special election in Indiana was back in 1989 in this very district (numbered the 4th back then), where Democrat Jill Long won an upset to fill the vacancy left by Dan Coats (who got promoted to the Senate to fill the vacuum left by Dan Quayle). Long went on to get swept out by Souder in 1994, and as Jill Long Thompson mounted a very poor comeback in the 2008 gubernatorial race. (H/t IndianaProgressive.) Also, it turns out that state Sen. Marlin Stutzman, last seen acquitting himself well in the Senate primary against Coats, is from this district (he's from tiny Howe, in LaGrange County). I wonder if he'd be interested in parlaying his newfound celebrity with the DeMint wing into another run for a promotion? (H/t izengabe.)

Finally, here's some legal background from Indiana's Secretary of State:

2) When will the special election be held?

Under Indiana Code 3-13-3-2, the circuit court clerk of the county where the U.S. Representative resided (in this case, Marion County) must certify that the vacancy has occurred, and file the certification with the Governor.

The Governor will then issue a writ of election that must specify the date of the special election (IC 3-10-8-3). There is no deadline specified by law for either the clerk's certification to be filed or for the Governor's writ to be issued.

However, the combination of deadlines set by state law for nominating candidates and absentee ballot voting makes it mathematically impossible for a special election to occur earlier than 60 days after a vacancy occurs in the office of U.S. Representative (See, for example, IC 3-13-1-7; 3-13-1-9; 3-13-1-20; 3-8-6-13; 3-8-7-15).

Just to clarify, this means that the "within 60 days" timeline that the Politico identified back in 2008 is incorrect.

DavidNYC :: IN-03: Mark Souder (R) Resigning Due to Affair with Staffer
Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

You all can look up a diary I wrote several months back
Predicting that 2010 would be a boring, every incumbent win easily, "nothing to see here" election.

Whoops!!!!!!


Quite.
Of course, that was before Bayh.

And Buyer.

And Ellsworth.

And now Souder.

Plus if Rokita gets elected to IN-04, we'll need a new SoS.

Ironically, the two guys who I was expecting to be in the most trouble - Visclosky and Burton - both survived their primaries, Visclosky unopposed. Wouldn't be surprised if Burton packs it in next cycle, though.

You were right about one thing, though - 2012 is going to be an interesting year. Way moreso now than we'd expected 6 months ago.


[ Parent ]
2010
it is still 2010

[ Parent ]
We
will definitely have a new SoS considering it is up for election this year, and besides Rotika was already term limited before running for Congress.    

Proud member of the Indiana Democratic Party from IN-9.  

[ Parent ]
NonPartisan has a diary on the D candidate in IN-03
http://www.swingstateproject.c...

In a series of comments here at SSP, I've argued that the IN-03 congressional race is the sleeper race of the 2010 cycle.  In this diary, I'll expand on these comments and explain in detail why I think Democratic candidate Dr. Tom Hayhurst has a real shot at pulling the upset of 2010 here in Indiana

I guess this is no longer a "sleeper" race.


and his chances
just improved a good bit

[ Parent ]
And this is why
it is important to get good, quality, potentially electable candidates in as many races as possible.

I totally think this is no longer a sleeper race.  Dr. Hayhurst is a perfect fit not just for a conservative district, but also for an anti-Washington election (and especially in a conservative district that just saw their conservative congressman caught with his pants down).


[ Parent ]
also, this when we should say a big THANK YOU
to michael steele for being repub party chair at a time when repub fundraising should be far ahead of where they currently stand; the dems will be able to put money into these type of seats and pull off some true stunners on E-DAY that will diminish the overall losses

[ Parent ]
We dont need a specific reason to be tahnkful for Steele
He's the gift that keeps on giving, each and every day.

[ Parent ]
an open seat
we can at least contest this seat which stretches the already limited resources of the nrcc a bit further

And it's a really cheap district for us to throw some $$ into


[ Parent ]
what is wrong with these people?
It's amazing to me that so many politicians still think they will get away with these affairs. I suppose that for every one who's caught, five continue to get away with it, and that gives others hope.

you are being kind
i think the percentages of those that actually get caught is much lower

[ Parent ]
Let me guess
Did this come to light when the female aide found out he didn't really serve in Vietnam?

Good one Adam!
Thank you.

[ Parent ]
can we now get a tea-bagging nominee?
how did the tea-baggers do in the primary? does anyone here know?

What's the profile of the guy Souder beat in the primary
Bob Thomas - is he one of the auto dealers who was against cash for clunkers?

Seems like he'd be an option for Rs to replace Souder.


A basic overview of IN-03
Indiana's 3rd Congressional district probably has changed less than any other in the state over the last few rounds of redistricting.  A geographically compact square, it takes in the NW corner of the state, centered in Fort Wayne.

Let's not kid ourselves -- this is a really tough nut to crack for Democrats.  Unlike some districts which have historically been conservative but Democratic (the South), or others that historically have been Republican but not very conservative (such as the Chicago or Philly 'burbs), this area has been both quite conservative and Republican for over a century.

That said, it has sent Democrats to Congress, most notably Ed Rouch in the 1970s, and Jill Long Thompson in the early 1990s.  Democrats can win there, if they are: 1) Seen as moderate enough, and 2) Perhaps more importantly, trusted as members tied into the local community (this was Montagano's biggest problem last time, and perhaps Dr. Hayhurst's biggest asset).

The key for any Democratic win, and one aspect of the district perhaps slowly changing in our direction, is Fort Wayne proper.  The city itself has about 35-40% of the district's population, and Dr. Hayhurst or any Democrat who wants to win the district has to come out of FW with a solid margin, because when you go elsewhere in the district, finding potential Democratic votes gets really hard.  The two places any Democrat just gets slaughtered is Elkhart County (the parts that moved in Obama's direction are largely in IN-02), and especially Kosciusko County, which in 2008 was Obama's worst county in the state.

So, difficult, yes!  Impossible, no!  In 1989, Jill Long Thompson scored a stunning upset in a special election (to replace, of all people Dan Coats, who took Dan Quayle's place in the Senate when Quayle became VP).  She won primarily because the Republican party was bitterly divided over who should be their nominee.  Maybe a somewhat similar type of chaos could put a Doctor in the House this fall!


That's pretty much what I was thinking.
Obviously, you know the area better than I do having lived here a lot longer, but I was always under the impression that Souder's biggest problem was Fort Wayne. Pretty ironic, considering he lives there himself. Guess they all know him.

The best thing Dems have going for them here is that Souder having waited until two weeks AFTER the primary really screws the Republican field, while our nominee is already set and can keep campaigning, introducing himself, and building up momentum. The problem is that Souder leaving takes away his best argument for change in a year whose theme is quickly becoming "My longtime incumbent Congressman sucks". In any other year, I'd say that Souder leaving abruptly mid-cycle was a good thing; this year I'm not so sure.  


[ Parent ]
This is State Sen. Marlin Stutzman district.
I believe IN-03 is State Sen. Marlin Stutzman district.

I guess he would be the clear GOP frontrunner for this seat and could be as tough to beat as a pre-scandal Souder would have been.

Fight global warming & help disaster relief efforts by raising money for Music for Relief when you search the web! Click here for more info:
http://searchmfr.swagbucks.com...


I actually think this could make this seat tougher to hold
That may be counterintuitive for an open seat, but it seems to me like Stutzman would be an upgrade, and I think it might be true of some of the other replacements as well.

This is a pretty Republican seat. Tough to win even with a good candidate.  


[ Parent ]
I don't think so, unless you're suggesting a damaged Souder...
...is the Republican.

But rank-and-file Republican voters have fully embraced hypocrisy on morality, completely excusing their philandering electeds over and over again while demanding abstinence from America.

I think we're better off here with an open seat.

43, male, Indian-American, Democrat, VA-10


[ Parent ]
Yes but they are more

I look to the state senate and they are easily 5 or 6 GOP state senators what can look to the seat. So I think he would not be the frontrunner. No clear frontrunner here.

GOP has too the Mayor of Forth Wayne. For compare, they are two state senate seats only based in Forth Wayne (both with republican incumbents).


[ Parent ]
No -- the Mayor of Fort Wayne is Tom Henry, a pretty progressive Democrat


[ Parent ]
Seriously, politicians.
Fuck.  Your.  Wife.

We need a rec comments feature stat!
That deserves a +1.  Go say that on DailyKos or MyDD so I can rec it.

Follow the elections in Georgia at the 2010 Georgia Race Tracker.

[ Parent ]
What in the purple hell
has gotten into the political water the last few days.  First Kendrick Meek is in bed with a developer and got paid quite handsomely for it, then Richard Blumenthal lies out his ass about his military record, now Mark Souder has an affair with a staffer.  

This has got to be one of the craziest 48-hour periods I've ever seen in politics.

23, Male, Democrat, OH-13


I'm just happy it's a conservative and a Republican this time.


Follow the elections in Georgia at the 2010 Georgia Race Tracker.

[ Parent ]
And I'm just disappointed
That he wasn't having an affair with a dude. Because that would've just been the cherry on top of the hypocrisy sundae.

Still, the fact he made an abstinence video with the (married) lady he had an affair does vault this scandal into the rarified heights of supreme hypocrisy, achieved only by such luminaries as Ted "Meth & Massage" Haggard and George "Rentboy" Rekers.  

Kansan by birth, Californian by choice, and Gay by the grace of God.


[ Parent ]
THAT would have been hilarious.
I'm waiting for a sex scandal involving two sitting politicians.  Anyone up for a John Boehner-Phil Gingrey scandal?

Follow the elections in Georgia at the 2010 Georgia Race Tracker.

[ Parent ]
Wasn't Gingrey the guy
With the tea bags on FOX? It boggles the mind!

[ Parent ]
Yep.
And (formerly) the 1970s gay porn mustache.

Follow the elections in Georgia at the 2010 Georgia Race Tracker.

[ Parent ]
Dude
Dude, that's just gross. I'm gay, but even a fleeting thought about gay sex between those two made me vomit in my mouth in a little.  

Now Paul Ryan & Aaron Schock is a different matter ... but Gingrey-Boehner sounds like some sort of horrible STD.

Kansan by birth, Californian by choice, and Gay by the grace of God.


[ Parent ]
I'm just hoping the next crazy-ass story affects the Republicans
I can see it now: "Breaking: Chuck Grassley resigns seat due to Squirrel Scandal. More at 11" :D

Politics and Other Random Topics

24, Male, Democrat, NM-01, Chairman of the Atheist Caucus, and Majority Leader of the "Going to Hell" caucus!


[ Parent ]
"Senator Grassley, when did you stop screwing squirrels?"


Follow the elections in Georgia at the 2010 Georgia Race Tracker.

[ Parent ]
Souder is the winner of the day

And in a very difficult day. Souder is a highly-gifted person

[ Parent ]
I'm not sure this is actually good from a viewpoint of taking the seat
Hayhurst is a good candidate and he's running strong but the main thing that made this race somewhat competitive to begin with was Souder's unpopularity.

My gut reaction is that if the race is generic Republican vs. Hayhurst, we lose, just because of the district's partisan lean.  

Independent Socialist & Chair of SSP Cranky Indianian Hoosier Caucus, IN-09


Well this at least helps divert some news cycle attention from Blumenthal......
Now we have some kind of moral equivalance, roughly speaking.  The talking heads will LOVE having multiple scoundrels to talk about today.

And Meek is actually the biggest winner of all, because his little possible-but-unclear scandal is less tasty than Blumenthal's and Souder's.

43, male, Indian-American, Democrat, VA-10


This is too rich!!!
Over on Kos, as part of the post on this whole thing, is a video of one of Souder's staffer's interviewing him over the necessity of abstinence-only sex education.  The rich part?  It's the very staffer he's been having an affair with!  Maybe he should have been advocating being faithful after one gets married, rather than celebate before one does!

See direct link above


[ Parent ]
The comedy routine really does write itself!


[ Parent ]
The staffer is kinda cute
I would let her lead me to Jesus any time.

[ Parent ]
Mike Pence is the only IN House Republican worth anything
But man oh man, he certainly does make up for the other deadbeats that constitute the Indiana House Republican delegation.

You being a conservative Republican ....
....  I can see why you'd say that.  And I've tried to tell people outside of Indiana not to underestimate him -- he has some serious political skills.

On the other hand, you've got to be disappointed not to get rid of Dan Burton!  If the anti-Burton faction had just one fewer candidate, he'd have been burnt toast.


[ Parent ]
I consider myself more of a moderate
But yeah, what's not to like about Mike Pence? He's telegenic, hits all the right notes on national security and fiscal policy, draws lots of attention and money for the party, and unlike others has integrity. Not bad for a guy from a district where Obama got 46%.

You all would adore the guy if he were a liberal Democrat.


[ Parent ]
Thanks to Souder

Just I was finding this article, and was here.

I wish give Souder my tribute :). We need more republicans like Souder.


That girl is out of his league n/t


NY-14, DC-AL (college) Distraught Mets fan

I'm not taking any pleasure in Souder's demise
For those of you who don't know me, please don't take this as me being "holier than thou"....

One of my closest friends got caught in an extra-marital affair, and it's about destroyed him.  I hate it not only for Souder, but more for his wife and kids.  I also hate it for his former supporters, although I probably have little in common with them.  

I've never cared for Souder's politics, and I really don't care to listen to him explain about his affair.  His behavior has a certain level of hypocrisy, but most of us that are mortals have displayed hyporcrisy at some time in our lifes.  

40, male, Democrat, NC-04


nitpick
If I am reading this right, then the circuit court clerk where the representative resided would be Allen County, not Marion County which lies outside the district.

Conservative family members living in the district never cared for Souder.  Not sure why exactly.  Hypocrisy gives off bad vibes?  They do like Stutzman though.
Stutzman won Kosciusko, Noble, Steuben, DeKalb, and LaGrange counties in the Senate primary.  Respectable second in Allen County (population center) against Coats who used to represent this district and resided in Fort Wayne.  I think Hayhurst would have to dominate Fort Wayne in order to remain competitive against Stutzman, who will sweep the rural areas of the district.


WOW!
Of all the days I have to stay late at the office! This made my day. I don't care if any of today's primaries go my way, today is a good day. We have a great candidate, although I know it's still and uphill battle but it's still a chance. Honestly I don't care about the special I am just glad Souder is gone.  

Proud member of the Indiana Democratic Party from IN-9.  


Copyright 2003-2010 Swing State Project LLC

Primary Sponsor

You're not running for second place. Is your website? See why Campaign Engine is ranked #1 in software and support among Progressive-only Internet firms. http://www.mediamezcla.com/

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About the Site

SSP Resources

Blogroll

Powered by: SoapBlox