Google Ads


Site Stats

AR-01: Republican Recruitment Fail

by: Crisitunity

Tue Mar 09, 2010 at 3:28 PM EST


Remember back when Marion Berry's retirement in the R+8, trending-the-wrong-direction AR-01 was going to hand one more vulnerable southern seat to the Republicans? Turns out... eh, not so much:

Arkansas' filing deadline passed Monday afternoon and while Republicans made a lot of noise about their chances in the 1st district in the days after Rep. Marion Berry (D) announced his retirement, all the sound and fury may have actually signified nothing....

In the end, the only Republican to join the contest after Berry announced his retirement was Princella Smith, a former congressional aide to freshman Louisiana Republican Rep. Anh "Joseph" Cao.

Smith will face off against the equally unknown and untested Rick Crawford, an Army veteran, farm broadcaster and businessman who entered the race in May 2009.

Republicans had sought to get one of several state legislators into the race -- state Sens. Davy Carter or Johnny Key. However, both said no, leaving the GOP without a backup plan. Meanwhile, top-tier Democrats piled into the race in this historically-Democratic district, including state Sen. Steve Bryles, former state Sen. Tim Wooldridge, state Rep. David Cook, and Berry's former CoS, Chad Causey. Like PA-12, here's a district where the Democratic tradition and the disparity between the two parties' benches may just save our bacon despite an ominous trend at the presidential level.

Filing information about the rest of the Arkansas races is here. AR-02 is still a very vulnerable seat to Republican takeover, with former US Attorney Tim Griffin armed with lots of money and Beltway connections. Dems still have a top-tier recruit here, though, state House speaker Robbie Wills, so even here we're in Tossup territory. Mike Ross in AR-04 seems to have emerged with only bottom-rung opposition, so hopefully he can contribute some time and money to shoring up the other races in the state. Democratic State Sen. Shane Broadway also seems poised to hold onto the Lt. Governor seat being vacated by Bill Halter; he faces off against only a pastor and a pizza restaurant owner.

RaceTracker Wiki: AR-01

Crisitunity :: AR-01: Republican Recruitment Fail
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Good news
I wonder if Berry regrets his decision for not running for re-election.

40, male, Democrat, NC-04

Johnny Key?
Wasn't he "big" in the 70's?

All about the money
and with the new ground rules for third party spending, corporations could swamp a field without it being obvious from a candidate's report.

That, and this is not a good year for elected officials and insiders. This post might be looking really badly predicted in 8 months.


Recruitment fail is fair
But sure, unheralded candidates do sometimes win.  

[ Parent ]
Exactly what i wanted to say
Especially in a "good year". Crawford, for example, can be not that great, but he seems to be at least decent candidate. In very good year that alone may be enough.

Smith? African-American Republican in district where only about 20% of population (and much less - in Republican primary) is black? I have strong doubts..


[ Parent ]
Money matters, but recruitment is very important...
Saying it's all about money ignores the importance of recruitment and ground game. The Democrats had a strong bench here and were able to recruit very credible candidates while the GOP came up short. Does this mean this seat is a sure bet for retention? Of course not. But it certainly makes the job easier. Add to this the Democratic advantage in party establishment in this district and I think this is a "Leans Retention" seat.

I think the Citizens United decision could have atrocious consequences when it comes to corporations potentially bankrolling candidates, but there's not any evidence to my knowledge that this is currently happening on a large scale or will happen in a district like this.  


[ Parent ]
Citizens United bigger impact on Senate/President races?
I just get the feeling that corps would rather take a shot at candidates at Senate or Presidential level. It just seems like ads from i.e.'s would stink too much in congressional districts to do anything except backfire. Just a feeling though.  

[ Parent ]
I think the ads would stink up almost every race
Such an easy way for your opponent to run negative ads against you for being bankrolled by whatever industry.

[ Parent ]
there's a chunk of people who
want a Palin clone over someone credible and qualified. And They're going to turn out in numbers.

The signs about turnout from the base are not good at all and I think people are fooling themselves a bit too much.


[ Parent ]
No
People are aware of it and are rightly concerned. Most recognize that passing HCR will go some way to closing the gap.

[ Parent ]
I don't think
I said anything more optimistic than "may just save our bacon." I might still rate this a Tossup, between it being open and the national environment, certainly nothing better than Lean D.  

[ Parent ]
Kinda figured this would happen
Arkansas Democrats still have a huge advantage in local races.  Republicans have a much weaker bench.  In time, that will change (possibly starting with their pickup of a US Senate seat), but in the meantime, if something opens up, top-tier Democrats pile in, and the Republicans struggle to find a good candidate.

They couldn't even come up with a decent candidate for Lt. Gov.  Wipe open race, could have picked anyone from around the whole state.  Nothing.


Before we get too overconfident though...
You can find examples in 2006 where the Dems had "recruiting failures" but managed to win the seat because of the national environment.

I still think this might be the year Arkansas gets away from the Dems. But we'll see.  


[ Parent ]
Aside from CSP, I can't think of one
Loebsack maybe, but he still raised as much money as Leach did.

Rick Crawford is not just a bad candidate, he's a bad candidate with no money. He's raised a whopping $110k with $62k on hand -- and that's over three quarters. The serious Democratic candidates will raise more than that by the end of the month.


[ Parent ]
Zach Space, maybe?
And Larry Kissell came close that year (but did not win, which might be to your point).  

[ Parent ]
Charlie Cook
Has changed this seat from a rating of "Lean R" to "Tossup", which I guess is good news for us although still seems a bit excessive. CQ Politics has moved it from "Tossup" to "Leans Democratic". One less race to worry about, I doubt we can lose this seat unless there's a scandal or really nasty primary election.

Until we see polling
Tossup is very fair. That is my own personal standard. Unless the PVI is ridiculously high.

[ Parent ]
Correct me if I'm wrong
I looks like statewide AR Republicans filed some dude for Gov, and Lt. Gov, a state Rep for SOS, and left Attorney General, Auditor, Treasurer and land Commissioner uncontested.  Is this accurate?

Recruitment fail in AR-1

AR-SEN will be it's own mess, but with the statewide field uncontested why do I suddenly feel optimistic in AR-2. already the most democratic district in the state as the powerhouse that is going to propel the other statewides over the top?

*See Gov. Bebe next to Dem candidate in AR-2 in ads over and over, and over again. Especially if it's the Speaker guy.

26, Male, Democrat, TX-26


Anyone have any insight into why
those Republican state senators declined to run for this seat?

"I'm not a member of any organized political party, I'm a Democrat!"
--  Will Rogers  


AR-03
On the other hand, isn't this rather a recruitment failure for us? Sure, Boozman's seat is conservative, but the three others are, too. We have one candidate, the GOP has 7, so is attorney David Whitaker somebody who can take on Cecile Bledsoe, Steve Womack or Kurt Maddox (the only three that have a shot, in my opinion)?

Just taking a look at the state's senate map, I guess that 7 of the 8 Republican senators are from this district (the 8th being Gilbert Baker, who is unfortunately not giving up his seat). We still at least had the option of courting Randy Laverty better than we did, and Sue Madison never ruled out a run.

And another check: maybe I'm just being stupid. 19 of the 28 Rs in the state house are from this district, which would leave us with only about 6.

Any chance of a race here?


Different kind of conservative
Eastern Arkansas is conservative, but historically Democratic, while the northwestern corner of Arkansas is historically Republican (check out the 1968 presidential maps -- Nixon cleaned up there, while Wallace won in the rest of the state). It also helps that Eastern Arkansas is where much of the state's black population lives, while the Ozarks are overwhelmingly white (although the Hispanic population is growing in the Bentonville area).

[ Parent ]

Copyright 2003-2010 Swing State Project LLC

Primary Sponsor

You're not running for second place. Is your website? See why Campaign Engine is ranked #1 in software and support among Progressive-only Internet firms. http://www.mediamezcla.com/

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About the Site

SSP Resources

Blogroll

Powered by: SoapBlox